Find therapists in Shelter Island

Dr. Cynthia Giocomarra

Are you looking for a therapist that actually "gets it"? Do you feel anxiety first thing in the morning, randomly throughout the day, or just before bed? Do you experience fear or panic reconnecting with friends, family, and coworkers since the pandemic hit? Are you in the process of (or thinking about) coming out and feel unsure of how to go forward? Are you wanting to restructure your life in a more meaningful way but not sure what your new life can look like? I can assist you. Let's talk.

Karla Rennhofer

Clients whom I’ve worked well with are often experiencing issues such as relationship problems, work stress/burnout, life transitions, low self-esteem, emotional abuse/neglect, childhood trauma/injuries, work/secondary trauma, anxiety, depression, and self-sabotaging behaviors. I've worked with creative people, such as writers and actors, to help bring their work to fruition. I also work with people in the medical/mental health/health fields, and those that work in high-tempo environments.

Greta MacMillan

My clients tend to be adults living with disabilities, mental or physical health issues, neurodivergence, and or are recovering from trauma. They want to find connection and healing while living in an ableist, rigid society. They have experienced spiritual/religious abuse and want to learn to use their unique brains and bodies to support their recovery. They have a sense of humor and are open minded, using creative strategies to heal.

Heather Keltai

We specialize in working with people who struggle with anxiety, OCD, self-esteem, and relationships. We help clients navigate challenging emotions, build confidence, and communicate openly, creating a supportive space for growth and healing.

Joie DeRitis

I specialize in supporting transgender and gender non-conforming people, polyamorous and non-monogamous folks, and those interested in kink and BDSM. I help people with depression, anxiety, grief and loss, trauma, gender and sexuality, sex and eroticism, interpersonal dysfunction, intrusive thoughts, body image, spirituality and religious trauma, life changes and transitions, and the shame and blame that linger from the past.

Paul Gaunya

I help individuals who are experiencing the weight of depression, anxiety, ADHD, trauma, and grief. My clients often experience unpredictable emotional states, struggling with focus and daily decision-making. They may have physical symptoms, sleep disturbances, or lose interest in activities they once enjoyed. Many feel isolated by an invisible burden that others can't see or understand. My clients are ready to work with someone who truly understands and uses proven methods to help them recover.

Shannon Kiley

We might be a good fit if... -If your relationship with music has been a lifeline for you -If your thoughts generally run in fifteen directions at once -If you toggle between overwhelm & burnout -If you're processing feelings about queer issues -If you're considering leaving or have left a high-demand religion -If you struggle with the big questions -If you're convinced there are better tools out there for managing your anxiety or your ADHD

Stephanie Condra

My clients span presenting issues and challenges. I know that sometimes taking the step to getting support and help in therapy seems overwhelming and I celebrate you for being here! I also know that the experiences you’ve had leading up to exploring therapy have likely been even more overwhelming, and that you deserve to feel relief, comfort, and care for and from yourself. I specialize in working with grief, loss, transition, and relational traumas which have disrupted your sense of Self.

David Piselli

At Ask an APRN PLLC, we make healthcare accessible and convenient with a blend of primary care and telehealth urgent care services. Whether you need a routine physical exam, help with weight loss, mental health evaluations and treatment for anxiety, depression, or ADHD, or just quick care for an urgent issue, we’re here to support your well-being. Our providers meet you where you are—offering both in-person and virtual care options tailored to your needs, ensuring seamless continuity of care.

Lisa Taylor-Austin

I can help you learn applicable coping skills to use in your daily life, and work through issues of concern, so you can feel better and have a more stress-free life. Approachable and down to Earth. Board Certified & Licensed. I work with clients, ages 18 & up, from vast backgrounds including culturally diverse populations & those who suffered moral injury. My many years of experience bring wisdom to your session. My approach is to help you, help yourself, to feel better &move forward.

Julie Jones

We currently specialize in treating children, teens, adults, couples and families. We have specializations in depression & mood disorders, anxiety & stress management, life transitions (i.e., separation/divorce, retirement, loss, going away to college), women’s issues, working with college students, perinatal/postpartum mental health, relationships/intimacy issues, substance abuse and trauma recovery.

Rachel Rosenberg

I specialize in working with people managing chronic illnesses, infertility, postpartum depression, trauma, anxiety, relationship issues and life transitions. These clients seek support, validation, and a compassionate listener.

Lourie Bonsu

At Resilience Lab I specialize in helping children, adolescents, adults, and families who have experienced trauma. That trauma can take any form — developmental, single-incident, or complex. Many people who have experienced trauma also face various mental health issues. I help them reclaim their lives. I have unique insight into the experiences of people who are immigrants, refugees, or survivors of sexual abuse.

Yma Campbell

My clients are anyone who presents me with an opportunity to help them. I believe in allowing my clients to drive the course of their path to treatment as they travel on their journey to healing. I serve as a personal coach to navigate to my clients while I embrace their ideas and support them through the process. I include a variety of activities and techniques to address some of the issues that are overwhelming and stressful in life.

Jul Gorman

My clients are the experts of their own experience, and my goal is to ensure that every client feels seen, heard, and valued in our therapeutic journey. My therapeutic framework is rooted in anti-racist, LGBTQAI-affirming, sex work-honoring values. I am committed to inclusivity, growth, and healing in a compassionate and non-judgmental space. My ideal client is someone who trusts enough in me and in the process to be honest with me about what they need while also being willing to learn together.

Sandra Tatroe

Are you struggling with feeling nervous, worried, fearful? Are you having a hard time getting through the day, feel depleted, and stuck? You're not alone and there is a light at the end of the tunnel! Don't know where to start? Let's chat about how I can help!

Jacqueline Fidelman

My ideal clients are motivated individuals who are navigating anxiety, relational and women's mental health issues, trauma, and significant life changes. They are looking to understand themselves better, overcome challenges, and lead more meaningful and authentic lives. I specialize in working with women, particularly around issues related to perinatal and postpartum mental health.

Briana Rogers

Are you someone who struggles with food and body image? You wake up in the morning proclaiming that you're going to be "better" that day, only to find yourself a few hours later in the same cycle? Does it seem like food runs your entire life? It can feel like no matter what you do, there's no way out of this trap you're in. In my work with clients I assist them in uncovering the reasons why food is controlling their life. It may seem like it's all about the food, but it's not.

Jason Powell

I am a nationally respected Marriage and Family Therapist (LMFT) with years of training and experience helping couples to navigate the most painful and difficult chapters in their relationship. I will guide you with compassion, empathy, and a skill set that is born in working with couples across the country in their healing journeys.

Donovan Beattie

I enjoy working with individuals aged 15 and older, especially those from the LGBTQ+ community and those navigating challenges like eating disorders. I believe everyone deserves to be heard, and my goal is to provide support, be a resource, and help clients navigate life in a positive way. My focus is on my clients’ well-being, whatever that may look like for them, and I aim to ensure they leave feeling just a little better than when they first arrived.